Sheep milk is temporarily in limited supply this time of year. Water Buffalo Milk is a great substitute because Sheep Milk and Water Buffalo Milk are similar in fat and protein. WB Milk is also easier to digest. Thanksgiving Turkeys Are Coming! Email us by November 1st to reserve your 12 to 16 pound turkey. 6.80 per pound for frozen. 7.10 per pound for fresh.

100% Grass-fed

Our beef, buffalo and dairy animals are 100% grass-fed. They are never fed grain. Dairy animals are given minerals and molasses in the winter as a supplement.

Raw A2/A2 Smoked Bleu Cheese

Raw A2/A2 Smoked Bleu Cheese

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Smoked Gruyere Cheese (8 oz)

Raw A2/A2 Smoked Gruyere Cheese (8 oz)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Bundle

Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Bundle

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Sharp Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw Sharp Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (2.5 lbs.)

Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (2.5 lbs.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (8oz.)

Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (8oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Round Roast

Round Roast

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Round Steak

Round Steak

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Rump Roast

Rump Roast

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Short Ribs

Short Ribs

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Sirloin Steak

Sirloin Steak

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Sirloin Tip Roast

Sirloin Tip Roast

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Skirt Steak

Skirt Steak

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Smoked Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Smoked Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Spleen

Spleen

Grass-Fed Beef

Sign up for pricing
Unsalted Baby Swiss (1lb)

Unsalted Baby Swiss (1lb)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Unsalted Baby Swiss 5 lb. Bundle

Unsalted Baby Swiss 5 lb. Bundle

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog Pt. (Glass)

Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog Pt. (Glass)

A2 Cow Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog, 1 Pt. Plastic

Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog, 1 Pt. Plastic

A2 Cow Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog, 1 Qt. Glass

Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog, 1 Qt. Glass

A2 Cow Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog, 1 Qt. Plastic

Vanilla Protein Shake/ Eggnog, 1 Qt. Plastic

A2 Cow Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Camembert Cheese (6 oz.)

Water Buffalo Camembert Cheese (6 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Gouda (1 lb.)

Water Buffalo Gouda (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Gouda (8 oz.)

Water Buffalo Gouda (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Paneer (1 lb.)

Water Buffalo Paneer (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
WB Sausage

WB Sausage

Water Buffalo

Sign up for pricing
WB 1st Colostrum, Frozen, Plastic

WB 1st Colostrum, Frozen, Plastic

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Arm Roast

WB Arm Roast

Water Buffalo

Sign up for pricing
WB Bone Broth - Frozen (Quart)

WB Bone Broth - Frozen (Quart)

Water Buffalo

Sign up for pricing
WB Bone Marrow

WB Bone Marrow

Water Buffalo

Sign up for pricing
WB Bone-In Ribeye

WB Bone-In Ribeye

Water Buffalo

Sign up for pricing
WB Butter, Cultured, Salted 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

WB Butter, Cultured, Salted 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Butter, Cultured, Unsalted, 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

WB Butter, Cultured, Unsalted, 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Butter, Salted, 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

WB Butter, Salted, 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Butter, Unsalted, 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

WB Butter, Unsalted, 8 oz. (Plastic) Frozen

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1 Gal. (Plastic)

WB Choc. Milk, 1 Gal. (Plastic)

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1 Pt. (Glass)

WB Choc. Milk, 1 Pt. (Glass)

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1 Pt. (Plastic)

WB Choc. Milk, 1 Pt. (Plastic)

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1 Qt. (Glass)

WB Choc. Milk, 1 Qt. (Glass)

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1 Qt. (Plastic)

WB Choc. Milk, 1 Qt. (Plastic)

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1/2 Gal. (Glass)

WB Choc. Milk, 1/2 Gal. (Glass)

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Choc. Milk, 1/2 Gal. (Plastic)

WB Choc. Milk, 1/2 Gal. (Plastic)

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Chocolate Ice Cream, 1 Pt.

WB Chocolate Ice Cream, 1 Pt.

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Colostrum, Frozen, 1 Pt. (Plastic)

WB Colostrum, Frozen, 1 Pt. (Plastic)

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Dandy Blend Ice Cream, 1 Pt.

WB Dandy Blend Ice Cream, 1 Pt.

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Egg Custard, 1 Pt. (Glass)

WB Egg Custard, 1 Pt. (Glass)

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Egg Custard, 1 Qt. (Glass)

WB Egg Custard, 1 Qt. (Glass)

Water Buffalo Raw Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
WB Gelato, Chocolate

WB Gelato, Chocolate

Water Buffalo Dairy-

Sign up for pricing
Return To Top

Learn

What We Sell

Buffalo Valley Pastures

  • 114 Pumping Station Road
    Quarryville PA 17566
  • Please call us at: (two-one-five) then 804-6551 (to deter spam calls!)