Goat Cottage Cheese is back! Sheep Kefir and Sheep Yogurt is temporarily discontinued due to the goat and sheep milk shortage that naturally occurs this time of year. Check for availability near the end of January or beginning of February.

Non-GMO

We do not use ingredients made from GMOs.

We do not feed our animals anything derived from GMOs.

Raw A2/A2 Garlic Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2/A2 Garlic Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese (1lb.)

Raw A2/A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese (1lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese (5 lb.)

Raw A2/A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese (5 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Sharp Cheddar Cheese (8 oz.)

Raw A2/A2 Sharp Cheddar Cheese (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Smoked Bleu Cheese

Raw A2/A2 Smoked Bleu Cheese

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Bundle

Raw A2/A2 Unsalted Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Bundle

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Sharp Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw Sharp Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (2.5 lbs.)

Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (2.5 lbs.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (8oz.)

Raw Shredded A2/A2 Cow Cheddar Cheese (8oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Return To Top

Learn

What We Sell

Buffalo Valley Pastures

  • 114 Pumping Station Road
    Quarryville PA 17566
  • Please call us at: (two-one-five) then 804-6551 (to deter spam calls!)