Sheep milk is temporarily in limited supply this time of year. Water Buffalo Milk is a great substitute because Sheep Milk and Water Buffalo Milk are similar in fat and protein. WB Milk is also easier to digest. Thanksgiving Turkeys Are Coming! Email us by November 1st to reserve your 12 to 16 pound turkey. 6.80 per pound for frozen. 7.10 per pound for fresh.

Pasture Raised

Whenever possible and as the seasons allow, our animals are raised on pasture and eat as they wish.

Buffalo Dairy Discovery Box Ships Free!

Buffalo Dairy Discovery Box Ships Free!

Raw Water Buffalo Dairy- For Cats and Dogs

Sign up for pricing
Buffarella Cheese, 8 oz.

Buffarella Cheese, 8 oz.

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Buffarella Cheese, Shredded, 8 oz.

Buffarella Cheese, Shredded, 8 oz.

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Buffeta Cheese 5 Pack Bundle Deal

Buffeta Cheese 5 Pack Bundle Deal

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Buffeta Cheese, 8 oz

Buffeta Cheese, 8 oz

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Fresh Buffalo Mozzarella 8 oz

Fresh Buffalo Mozzarella 8 oz

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Raw Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Camembert Cheese (6 oz.)

Water Buffalo Camembert Cheese (6 oz.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Gouda (1 lb.)

Water Buffalo Gouda (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Water Buffalo Paneer (1 lb.)

Water Buffalo Paneer (1 lb.)

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
WB Shredded Gouda Cheese, 8 oz.

WB Shredded Gouda Cheese, 8 oz.

Raw A2 Dairy Cheese

Sign up for pricing
Return To Top

Learn

What We Sell

Buffalo Valley Pastures

  • 114 Pumping Station Road
    Quarryville PA 17566
  • Please call us at: (two-one-five) then 804-6551 (to deter spam calls!)